TRAIN DELAYS, CANCELLATIONS AND COMPENSATION – PART 2 – 13/02/2018

I wrote about my Christmas travel problems in a blog on 4th January 2018, which I thought I had resolved on that day and I attach a link below for ease of reference;

https://thegrumpygit.com/train-delays-cancellations-and-compensation-04-01-2018

I should know by now at my age that I was being somewhat naive and optimistic to expect such efficiency in resolving any dispute, which is evidenced in my book and various blogs on this website.

So, without boring you with endless e-mails, I e-mailed this individual who promised me with a refund on 10/01/2018;

Hello,

 

I posted the tickets by recorded delivery on 4 January, which I believe you have received now.

 

I would therefore be grateful if you could kindly confirm that a refund has been applied to my card.


I look forward to hearing from you, and thank you in advance for your assistance.
 

Best wishes,

 

Scott.

 

Steven promptly replied the following day (11/01/2018);

Hi Scott,

That’s great, if you could forward the recorded delivery tracking number I’ll get our refunds team to locate the tickets and get the refund processed.

Regards

Steven
Customer Service Representative

A few e-mails were exchanged and Steven concluded by saying on 12/01/2018;

Hi Scott,

I’ve passed the details of the recorded delivery on to our refunds team and they will locate this and process the refund.

I’ll let you know once this has been processed.

Regards,

Steven
Customer Service Representative

I sent a few chaser e-mails over the following two weeks, which were ignored, so I chose to visit their HQ which is less than 4 miles from my home and spoke to Laura on 25/01/2018.

Laura tried to redirect my claim to Virgin Trains despite the fact that my contract was made with Trainline, who sent me texts and e-mails days earlier saying that my travel arrangements were fine although the train was cancelled days earlier.

Subsequent confusion arose as I had used the tickets on trains I had been bumped on to, which led Trainline to believe that my trains were delayed.  I thought that I had clarified the position at that time in person, although I didn’t expect another clown to jump in with his inflammatory input at the same time.

You can see where this is going and Madhavi wrote as I left the HQ to say;

Dear Scott,

I have received some mail from you relating to booking reference xx (collection reference xx).

There’s a copy of everything that was in the envelope attached to this e-mail. The envelope includes used outward portion and the return portion ticket.  In order to process the refund amount requested we require the complete set of unused tickets (outward and return). As the outward ticket is used we will not be able to process the refund amount requested.

If you have any queries, please feel free to contact us.

Kind regards,

Madhavi
Customer Service

I thought that my response below would have cleared it up, although I had to lower my expectations even further and simplify my explanations to try and make myself understood.

Dear Madhavi,

I have just returned from your office after speaking to Laura direct, so please take a look at the notes on my account. 

I shall make this easy for you to follow by providing my explanation in bullet points;

  • My train was cancelled due to train strikes
  • I was advised by texts and e-mails days beforehand that my travel arrangements were fine
  • My train was cancelled days earlier and I was not advised so I could make alternative arrangements
  • Although the tickets have been used, the subsequent delays with my travel meant that my weekend was ruined
  • Steven promised me a refund if I simply sent the tickets in by recorded delivery
  • You have received the tickets
  • I have not received a refund
  • Laura today has promised that a refund shall be made in due course and I expect this to be actioned

Please confirm that a refund is being processed so I do not have to visit your offices again.

I hope that makes sense and I expect this to be dealt within 7 days, otherwise I shall escalate this further.

Regards,

Scott.

Madhavi wrote to me on 27/01/2018 and incredibly responded with this;

Dear Scott,

Thank you for your recent e-mail.

I am sorry to know that you were delayed.  I apologise for the inconvenience faced.

From our end we can only process a refund on unused tickets.  As the tickets were used to complete the journey we will not be able to process a refund on it.  As a part of the Sales Support Team, we help our customers find the best priced tickets to make a journey but we do not actually manage the trains.  Compensation pertaining to delay is handled by the Customer Relations team of the relevant train operating company managing the route.

In order for me to forward your request to the right team, may I request you to please help me with the exact details of the service that was delayed/disrupted.  I will then find out the relevant details and forward your claim.

Awaiting your response,

Kind regards,

Madhavi
Customer Service

Madhavi didn’t have to wait long for my response, and I wrote by return with this e-mail;

Dear Madhavi,

Warm words doth butter no parsnips.

I thought I had explained myself clearly; evidently not so I shall try again.

  • My train was cancelled.  CANCELLED – NOT DELAYED
  • My contract is with Trainline
  • Trainline confirmed that my train arrangements were fine by texts and e-mails
  • Trainline did not give me the opportunity to make alternative arrangements
  • I was given alternative trains to use on the day (hence the tickets being used – well spotted)
  • Subsequent delays ruined my weekend
  • Steven promised me a refund immediately and said that he had raised this on receipt of the tickets
  • I have not been given a refund
  • I visited your offices on Thursday 25th January and spoke to Laura
  • I reiterated that my train was CANCELLED, not delayed, as Laura tried to get me to direct my query elsewhere
  • As my train was CANCELLED, Laura said that I should get a refund soon

Which part of this do you not understand?  Do I need to visit your offices to speak to you direct to clarify this?  My train was not delayed and as a result, Trainline have promised me a refund which I expect to be honoured.

I am happy to visit your offices once again if necessary and rest assured that if I do, I shall not be leaving until this is resolved.

Please advise.

Regards,

Scott.

Light partially dawned on Madhavi’s marble head, he understood that my train had been cancelled and I received the following reply;

Dear Scott,

Thank you for your recent e-mail.  I understand the service booked was cancelled.

As mentioned in the previous e-mail, from our end we can only request for a refund on unused tickets.  As the tickets were used to travel on an alternative service to complete the journey, we will not be able to process a refund on it.  All issues pertaining to cancellation, delay and onboard experience are handled by the Customer Relations team of the relevant train operating company managing the route.  Hence, I requested you to confirm the exact details of the affected service in order to forward your claim.

If you have any queries, please feel free to contact us.

Kind regards,

Madhavi
Customer Service

Anyway, I escalated this and various e-mails were swapped with a promise that a Manager would respond within 5 – 7 working days and call me.  Suffice to say, this was another empty promise and I visited their HQ yet again on 13/02/2018 once the 7th day elapsed and picked out Laura to speak to.

I laid it on the line that I was willing to take this to Court if I had to, although I had to be seen (by the Courts) to have explored all avenues and that I would be billing Trainline for my time.

The Courts see £10 a hour as a reasonable administrative cost and I put that to Laura, saying that the Courts would rule in my favour anyway with all costs being paid by Trainline for the sake of a £79 refund that I had been promised and was still outstanding two months later.

I summed it up by saying that although it’s clear that there has been a mix-up, the fact remains that Trainline sent me texts and e-mails saying that my travel arrangements were fine for a train that was cancelled days earlier.  I was never given the opportunity to make other arrangements and I wouldn’t try to travel on a cancelled train.

I asked to see the elusive Manager (not possible), and my final question was, “What’s going to happen now?”  Laura said, “I’ll get my Manager to ring you as soon as possible” and I said that I was promised that 7 working days ago and here I am sat at your office.

True to her word, her Manager called me within 10 minutes as I was sat in their car park with a promise that a full refund was being processed right now.

The crux of succeeding with any complaints is to be polite, succinct, summarise the issues you wish to address and the outcome you seek either as compensation or to restore you to the position you were in before you entered in to the contract.

I will swallow up as much time, money and resources as it takes until I get the result I want and nobody really believes it when I say so until I start warming to my theme.

I cover various aspects and real-life scenarios involving the Consumer Rights Act 2015 complete with templates based on real-life test cases that work in my book now on sale via Amazon as an e-book and paperback priced £2.99 / £7.99.

BBC Radio Scotland have read it and interviewed me as a consumer expert for a five-part consumer programme they are making.  Read a free sample via my website and let me know what you think?

DOWNLOAD to your Kindle or get the free Kindle app from Amazon and read the book on your IPad / tablet / smartphone / laptop.

Like and follow me on Facebook – The Complaints Resolver.

If you have enjoyed reading this, feel free to take a look at my other website http://www.awriterinedinburgh.com which showcases my writing and how you can work with me.

Advertisements